Adrian Lander is the Co-Founder of Agnostic Agile, one of the largest, leading and influential global Agile movements. He is also an industry veteran with more than 27 years global experience in Executive and Team coaching, Agile delivery, software product management (amongst other things).
I hold Adrian in high regard and wanted to here his thoughts on my last post titled Dysfunctional Patterns of Agile Teams. The following is what he had to say.
Adrian Lander on being Agile:
I have been a programmer and software developer since the mid 70s and am one of the few agile coaches who still develops software (him / herself), while I am working a lot with senior management, where my biggest value has been for past years. I do not need to still develop, but I want to. My heart is still with (agile) SW product development. It also helps me (still) understand deeply the work SW developers do nowadays.
Scrum often has done not much more than “transforming” teams with an – often – experienced (SW) Project Manager to a team with an – often – inexperienced “Scrum Process Manager”, with all promised attached and mostly unfulfilled in the end. And with some of the benefits, when there is more of a facilitation stance, there are also real risks and drawbacks with the often uninformed, unqualified, hands-off, “outside process coaching” focus. After the Scrum honeymooning period, one can often see fallback and rarely continuous improvement in capability. The framework becomes the new plateau, the new “method prison”, the box through which too many involved start to see the world.
Inherently, Scrum is a wrapper and has nothing to do with SW development.
People who were doing (early) agile SW development before Scrum and/or have been exposed to other approaches like XP, Kanban, Lean SW Development etc regularly see that.
Should programmers care? From an agile business benefits perspective – so where agile puts the first priority – yes. SW developers – I prefer that term – understandably may:
- think that it is not their responsibility, but for others to sort out (“let them do their job”)
- better than the command & control situation they got pulled into in the past
- as good as it gets in reality (“a job is a job”)
- less of a concern as they can work around and do their own thing
- all the same, whatever framework gets bought and pushed
But these are all situations of unfulfilled opportunities.
Reality is that we can create much better situations that are sustainable and further evolve.
But it takes time, structural change and commitment, harder to get skill sets all around, stamina and perseverance, vision & strategy, realism, etc. All the things rarely there in this often instant, superficial world of siloed commercial interests and existing, traditional power structures. In such contexts, the framework does not matter.
But even if we get the right context, the framework does not matter.
Practices do. Given we have been able to focus on the right WHAT. And also keep developing the context (the organisation).
But the framework is the easy, tangible part, we can train in, certify in, sell and even hold as the standard to explain all failure “when not followed strictly or understood” etc.
By then, the consultant can move on to a new client, a new sale, another few years of drawing money and collecting “experience” etc – without ever having to go deep.
The SW developers, product management people, other business stakeholders and customers get the consequences of this, after investing effort, $, time and trust. For them, it often is just another fad or “transformation”. And it will drive some to want to become an agile consultant (Scrum Master, coach, career trainer etc) – more money, more “status”, further away from where the pain is felt.
It all has nothing to do with agile, though. It’s The Industry that has been created. Changing the World of Work, it’s called. E.g. through Scrum’s 13 page rule book, after a 2 day’s rebirth session from a guru-certified disciple (aka Scrum Superspreader).
– Adrian Lander, Co-Founder of Agnostic Agile
Thank you Adrian for taking the time to write about your experiences with Agile over the last 27 years. I’m grateful to learn from them and be able to reproduce them here for the benefit of others
Frank Ray & Associates is a software engineering consultancy that builds high quality software for businesses.